Livelihood matters, but human lives, environmental security, and the future of Catanduanes must come first.
The impending coal mining operation in Barangay Obi, Caramoran, is raising serious concerns among residents of nearby Barangay Hitoma and other sectors. The growing opposition is not necessarily opposition to development; it is a demand for responsible development that does not sacrifice public safety and environmental protection for economic gain.
Catanduanes is a typhoon-prone province, constantly exposed to heavy rainfall, flooding, soil erosion, and landslides. Any activity that may disturb the natural landscape, vegetation, and drainage systems must undergo rigorous scientific assessment. For communities downstream, the question is simple: who will bear the consequences if something goes wrong?
Mining proponents may promise employment, investments, and additional government revenues. These are legitimate economic considerations. But how do temporary economic benefits compare with the possibility of damaged agricultural lands, contaminated water sources, disrupted livelihoods, and increased environmental vulnerability?
The 1987 Constitution, Article II, Section 16, guarantees the people’s right to a balanced and healthful ecology. RA 7942, or the Philippine Mining Act, and PD 1586, establishing the Environmental Impact Statement System, provide safeguards that must be strictly observed. Meanwhile, RA 10121, or the Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act, demands that disaster risks be integrated into development decisions.
The DENR, MGB, EMB, and concerned local governments must therefore provide clear answers. Are the geological, hydrological, and landslide risks adequately assessed? Have the affected communities been meaningfully consulted? Are the permits and environmental safeguards sufficient to protect Hitoma and neighboring barangays?
The people must not be asked to trust promises when their safety is at stake. Transparency, independent scientific evaluation, and genuine public consultation are not obstacles to investment; they are essential conditions for responsible development.
Caramoran needs livelihood, but it does not need a livelihood that may endanger lives. Catanduanes needs investment, but not at the expense of its environment.
If mining can be proven safe, lawful, and sustainable, let the evidence speak. If serious and unmanageable risks remain, the government must have the courage to stop it.
Coal can generate income, but no amount of coal can replace a lost life, a destroyed watershed, or a community stripped of its future. Development is meaningless if the people it promises to uplift are the very people it puts at risk.
